• 2 Posts
  • 141 Comments
Joined 8 months ago
cake
Cake day: November 11th, 2024

help-circle
  • As a person living next to Russia, I tend to follow it’s situation. I know that the exports from Russia to India has been declining for years, following India moving (not all yet) production of weaponry home. Only oil remains strong.

    Also India - I think - seems to be projecting more and more “Western” image. Not sure why. Maybe my perception is skewed here, because the CEOs of biggest corporations sound more and more indian every year. Maybe it’s Modi skipping Shanghai Cooperation Agreement summit - and generally avoiding public places where Putin is - since Russian invasion of Ukraine.

    So while Russia and India will remain trade partners and probable allies, I think they are currently trying to figure out how to increase their trade ties (and India might be wanting to be hush hush about it for Western publicity). There might be other challenges there - if I remember correctly, the current trade flow is that India buys significantly more from Russia than it sells there, so they might want to increase their exports - but this is totally my opinion.

    I know there were plans for more ports and trade corridors before the Ukraine invasion, but I don’t know their status now.

    India Russia hate each other to the bone

    I don’t think so. Russia supported India during Cold War, didn’t it? It also stood with India during India-Pakistani War. That counts for a lot, especially with older folks - and politicians tend to be older folks.










  • The famine was the produce of a great number of different factors, inefficient and backward agricultural methods, bad weather, compound effects of WW2 + the Chinese civil war, mismanagement, trade embargoes, etc… But others could explain it better than I can.

    Would the governing body of PRC in 1962 attributing the famine to government errors convince you otherwise? Would the Chinese government 20 years later confirming the same and reiterating it was the Mao policy that was faulty at the core convince you?

    If not, can you imagine a fact that would convince you, that the responsibility for that famine is on the then Chinese government? What is it?


  • You’re talking about narrative, spin a story about tribunal, and then spin a story that I’m defensive. I’m not.

    Insisting that the event happened the way you say it did without providing any rational or cause-effect relationship

    Literally what the first commenter gave - there was a widespread famine in China, it’s caused by Mao agricultural policies.

    What are you contesting here? There was no famine? Famine is the narrative? Or that it wasn’t caused by policies but by… What? Weather? Weather was good.

    I don’t understand your point, please clarify it, in a way that isn’t just calling your interlocutors stupid or defensive.


  • It’s not paywalled. I think you didn’t even bother to click “read full article” or whatever the button name is. They might ask you to register witb a free account.

    If you want to use other people opinions as an argument, I’m going to ask you for what you asked for - studies. Preferably published in journals, not essays by socials celebrities like Caitlin Johnstone, nor articles in Chinese newspapers, nor Reddit. And that’s because a deluge of weak sources is worthless - that’s how US propaganda works and enforces itself.

    Extra points if the studies are not from China or it’s close Allies, just so that you have exactly the same requirements as the ones you asked for.

    Can be paywalled.

    Edit: I highly recommend you read https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gish_gallop








  • Well, I don’t know your use case well enough, but I guess you might have perfect reason for that behavior.

    One thing that comes to my mind is the old Try in C#

    bool parsedSuccessfully = int.TryParse("123", out int result);
    

    But I guess more popular approach would be to use Error as Values, right?

    E.g. something like this

    Outcome<Exception, Int> result = int.TotallyNewParse("123");