In short i just jumped into the whole Mastodon blocking drama and am somewhat disappointed to see it as childish as reddit’s power mod drama. Accelerated by the fact that a Limit/Mute option exist just fine, i wonder why Block/Defederation is an option at all. It only moves power from the user to admins without anything in return. With just Mute, as far as i can tell, one still wouldn’t have to look on certain instances, but could interact/whitelist certain individuals and we’d get rid of the multi account requirement overnight. So why isn’t it that way?

  • breden@reddthat.comOPEnglish
    0·
    8 months ago

    As far as I understand it, content posted to one server gets stored on every federated server for the other server’s users to see.

    This is wrong, else every self hosted instance would’ve been a storage nightmare.

    There have been instances that were defederated for posting nazi / racist content, and CSAM

    I assume the later is something CP? Yes, those are legimite cases, just like spam/DdoS, but even then in every case i’ve seen yet, a Limit would’ve been enough. A pretty good example seems to be qoto.