• NOSin@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    10 months ago

    “Academic philosopher Michael V. Antony (2010) argued that despite the use of Hitchens’s razor to reject religious belief and to support atheism, applying the razor to atheism itself would seem to imply that atheism is epistemically unjustified. According to Antony, the New Atheists (to whom Hitchens also belonged) invoke a number of special arguments purporting to show that atheism can in fact be asserted without evidence.”

    If only you could read, maybe you’d be more tolerant, but I doubt it, sigh.

    • Beemo Dinosaurierfuß@feddit.de
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      10 months ago

      The sheer arrogance to post a philosophical minority opinion paired with an insult and then end it with a sigh.

      And while I am not particularly familiar with Mr. Antony’s work I can tell you that he either didn’t understand or purposefully misused Hitchen’s Razor insofar as you indeed can not apply it to Atheism the same way you can apply it to christianity.
      The reason for that being that there is no particular thing at all you have to believe to be an atheist.
      Atheism in and of itself doesn’t assert anything at all.
      So there is nothing that could be dismissed.

      Atheism says there is no reason to believe in god.
      How does Hitchen’s Razor dismiss that? It doesn’t.

      Not to mention your quote still is no argument towards the positive existence of god.

      And if you don’t show me how I am supposed to be intolerant, I will take it as the baseless insult that it is and will no longer discuss with you.

      • NOSin@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        edit-2
        10 months ago

        Atheism says gods doesn’t exist. So yes, it very much goes both way.

        Stop moving the goal post. You’re just an intolerant cunt that freely bash on people, insisting that any form of belief is bad, because you can’t conceive a good one in your defective brain.

        I’m not trying to prove that gods exist, as unlike you, I’m not saying gods exist, because I don’t care about proving or disproving either way. I don’t feel so egocentric that I need others people to feel like I do.

        It helps some people, and the only viable and truly defensible position is agnosticism. And like everything with humans, yes, it is sometimes used for evil. If that’s your argument, you’re against everything a human can ever use and you should become an hermit.

        A cunty intolerant hermit, when you think about it, which would prolly help people more than the stupid points you’re trying to make.

        PS : You’ve already proven your incredibly limited view by stating before that religion = Christianity basically.