The service offers the ability to purchase credits through cryptocurrencies, as well as offers the data for AI training purposes.
I don’t have a Discord history, so that’s one problem taken care of.
Just never talk in a public server and it still won’t.
Another reason not to use Discord.
You should learn about how message federation works on Lemmy
I love pets
You have to pay for it…
From the article, the data collection hinges on a bot going into a public server then scraping the history. Still a problem that Discord should act on, but it looks like there is no need to worry about private servers.
“private” = small ‘servers’ that aren’t in the public index (I think you have to have like 500 people to be eligible or something), or…?
You literally just set the server to private, which is invite-only and has slightly less features. Any public/community server is in the public index.
I’ve ran a discord server for 8 years and I have 0 recollection of this setting. Where is it?
Are you running a server which has a “community server” badge on it or using disboard?
Hmm, it seems like the option is actually the reverse: for toggling whether it’s a community server. So to make it private you simply click on the button to disable community features.
You also used to be able to only disable discovery but that was bundled into community features.
Ah, thanks! My server is a community server but isn’t eligible for discovery, so… I guess we are safe?
Does anyone know what kind of naming pattern or bot identification methods we could use? I belong to a small public server that’s there to serve a public need.
You could probably have a verification system thing that I’ve seen some public servers have where you have to complete some action before getting access to the actual channels.
Time to switch to alternative open source ones: Revolt, Matrix, Spacebar…
Revolt looks and functions the most like Discord.
it redirects to a video of the infamous Jonah Jameson’s “Are you serious?” scene from Spider-Man
No, it hosts the video. DMCA!!1!!1!!!
Deleted discord recently because of the ads. Glad I did as iv been looking for reason to delete it for a while.
This… this is nothing. Oh no, my messages on public servers are being scraped! Good thing I haven’t said anything in a public server I didn’t fully intend on being there forever.
The Discord haters will feast on anything. Granted, this should still be shutdown as a TOS violation but acting like this is a profound intrusion on privacy? Get ahold of yourselves. This is no different from Tweets being scraped or Facebook wall posts. Don’t add the bot to servers you don’t want it on and it’s a nonissue.
the content being scraped is from users, they do not control what bots are added to servers.
It’s much more like the Cambridge Analytics scandal in that users posted content that was shared with friends but not explicitly shared publicly, but those friends then granted a third party access to all of the data.
This is assuming the bots are allowed (or, at least not prevented in coming) in by the server admin and the bot is not obfuscated some how. If the bots are taking advantage of an expolit, or not being up front, then we have trouble.
If they could somehow make this data available to search engines. Maybe we can start being able to google random problems and actually find solutions again.
Search engines would have to function but yeah that would be nice.
What kind of foolish optimist are you? Search engines are to make profit, not help you find that obscure answer to your urgent question
Excited to see Discord do absolutely nothing about this despite it being an egregious breach of their TOS.
Discord‘s TOS only really applies when they feel like it.
Just like twitch
When someone uses 3rd party client or creates a server for Nintendo emulator
…and when they don’t pay Discord under the table. Discord wouldn’t be unique if this was the case either.
Can’t wait for it to die and wither out. But I know they will retain a big pool of users on hostage like reddit or fb for a while.
Is matrix.org a viable alternative as of now or the near future?
personally I think revolt is a better alternative.
Matrix is great, if only I could convince my friends to use it.
If it has the same issues Lemmy does, probably not. People don’t want to build an account on a server only to find out, three months later, it’s run by tankies, or anti-piracy watchdogs, or any other number of unsavory things.
I am still on it because of a small circle of friends.
I think they’ll give it a genuine shot. These stalking services pop up like weeds and every time it gets some media attention they end up with significant problems not much later.
dis.coolwas the last well-known entry but there’s been more.
